Nigeria: Buhari must walk the talk on spending
As Nigeria's debt continues to rise amidst declining oil revenues, analysts are warning that the country must cut its coat according to the available cloth.
“If annual debt service cost is 110% of govt revenue, FG must implement the Oronsanye [sic] Report & cut down [the] size of government”, tweeted Ayisha Osori, executive director for the Open Society Initiative for West Africa.
If annual debt service cost is 110% of govt revenue, FG must implement the Oronsanye Report & cut down size of govt – not increase ministers from 36 to 42; not create new MDA.
Foreign trips & estacodes are the tip of the iceberg; a lot more sacrifice required from govt.
— Ayisha Osori (@Naijavote) October 21, 2019
The civil society leader’s comments are the latest in a set of warnings by concerned stakeholders over the past few months.
- In June 2019, former central bank governor Sanusi Lamido Sanusi warned that the country was on the verge of bankruptcy, saying that fuel subsidies have entrenched underdevelopment and is boosting poverty.
- “What happened is that the Federal Government pays petroleum subsidy, pays electricity tariff subsidy, and if there is a rise in interest rates Federal Government pays”, the former governor, now Emir of Kano, told the National Treasury Workshop. “[…] If truly President [Muhammadu] Buhari is fighting poverty, he should remove the risk on the national financial sector and stop the subsidy regime, which is fraudulent.”
While government costs and debts are piling up, Africa’s largest economy continues to operate a large government.
- Between 2015-2018, Nigeria spent N6.46trn ($17.84bn) to service debts, according to numbers from the Debt Management Office (DMO).
- A May 2019 presentation by finance minister Zainab Ahmed revealed that two-thirds of revenues due to federal government after allocation to the states and local governments goes into servicing Nigeria’s debt obligations.
- In 2018, N2.15trn was spent servicing debt and a similar amount has been earmarked for 2019. For 2020, N2.45trn is budgeted for servicing debt.
Beyond that, the cost of governance is also on a steady rise.
A breakdown by BudgIT, a frontline nonprofit advocating for transparency and fiscal accountability of governments across West Africa, shows that recurrent expenditure has increased year-on-year since 2016 and a record N7.8trn is budgeted for it in 2020.
10. The Budget still has elements of waste in the 2020 projected budget as the recurrent expenditure that has grown over the years is not reducing. However, several capital items in the budget are not specific neither are they needed considering the revenue crunch. pic.twitter.com/7BtyOMr9yG
— BudgIT Nigeria (@BudgITng) October 19, 2019
Projected non-debt recurrent expenditure (overheads and personnel) for 2020, is N4.8trn.
— BudgIT Nigeria (@BudgITng) October 8, 2019
After winning re-election in February 2019, President Buhari announced a 43-man cabinet in August of the same year. Four years ago, he had reduced the overall number of ministers from 42 to 36 and streamlined the ministries to 25.
The members of the new cabinet supervise a largely redundant civil service which continues to accumulate salaries and hike the cost of salaries and overheads in the annual budget, on a yearly basis.
Get your free PDF : Top 200 banks 2018
Opportunity knocks again
Complete the form and download, for free, the highlights from The Africa Report’s Exclusive Ranking of Africa’s top 200 banks from last year. Get your free PDF by completing the following form
Civil servants, especially the retinue of government advisers, make up a bulk of the large delegations that accompany members of the executive at federal and state levels on a plethora of foreign trips. There are also frequent allegations of ‘ghost workers’ in the service, a term for nonexistent workers whose salaries go down on the balance sheet.
- The Oronsaye report is an 800-page report submitted to Buhari’s predecessor, Goodluck Jonathan, by Stephen Oronsaye, a former head of the civil service and head of a committee constituted by the then-president to tackle civil service reforms. It called for a shrinkage of government, with as many as 102 parastatals and agencies recommended for scrapping. The report, which also called for an audit of selected government agencies, has never been implemented to this day.
- Back in 1999, another committee with a similar mandate was established under the leadership of another former civil service head, Ahmed Joda. It made similar recommendations to both the Oransaye report and an earlier one – the Allison Ayida committee of 1995.
In what is hopefully an indication of more to come, Buhari ordered a forensic audit of the Niger Delta Development Commission (NDDC)‘s operations from 2001 to 2019. Established under the Olusegun Obasanjo administration to trigger development in the oil-rich region, the commission has for years had the reputation of a corrupt institution and is widely believed to have become a cash cow for funding elections in the Delta.
But that is only a drop in the ocean.
Why this is important: Talk of reducing the size and cost of governance has gone on in Nigeria’s corridors of power for decades but has remained just that – talk. There is no better time than now for Nigeria to walk the talk and prune its government and pinch the pennies to be able to deliver dividends of democracy to its citizens.