South Africa: African Rail Industry Association welcomes Transnet rail sale

In depth
This article is part of the dossier: Logistics in Africa

By Xolisa Phillip, in Johannesburg
Posted on Tuesday, 26 April 2022 15:35, updated on Wednesday, 27 April 2022 11:03

Transnet's Blue Train against a backdrop of Table Mountain in Cape Town
Transnet's Blue Train against a backdrop of Table Mountain in Cape Town, South Africa. (AP Photo/TRANSNET)

Transnet has announced that it will sell slots of its rail network to third parties in an effort to liberalise the the rail sector, but the African Rail Industry Association (ARIA) argues that current terms placed on the table by the state owned company may limit investor appetite.

Transnet Freight Rail (TFR), the state-owned logistics company’s biggest of six operating divisions with reported revenue of R39.4bn ($2.5bn) in 2021, announced the commencement of a rail slots sale at the beginning of April.

Third-party operators have until 31 May to submit bids, and TFR is expected to announce winning bidders on 30 June.

“We think it [access] will bring prices down. We need this,” says Mesela Nhlapo, CEO of ARIA.

“Business is ready to invest, and that’s what the president wants. But the market must be investor friendly,” Nhlapo says.

In total, 16 slots are open to interested investors: six slots on the Durban to Johannesburg corridor and ten on the Gauteng to East London corridor.

Durban to Johannesburg, known as the container corridor, links to inland container terminals in City Deep, Kascon, Pretcon, and Kaalfontein; and Gauteng to East London, referred to as the south corridor, is important for manufacturers, the automotive industry, and agriculture.

Winning bidders are obligated to obtain licences from the rail regulator, after which the third-party operators will be permitted to move cargo on rail around October 2022.

TFR is the infrastructure owner and operator on an estimated 31,000km of rail track covering a 20,911km route, making it the 11th-largest rail network in the world according to the government. TFR operates a core network route spanning 12,801km.

TFR has separated its accounts into infrastructure and operator in preparation for third-party access – part of long-awaited rail reform as articulated in the 2017 White Paper on National Rail Policy and now included in the Ramaphosa administration’s Operation Vulindlela, an expedited programme of structural reforms.

Capital costs

But ARIA, the representative body for original equipment manufacturers, rail operators, and rail component manufacturers, also argues that the current terms placed on the table by Transnet are a potential hindrance to investment.

According to ARIA, a 50-wagon trainset has a R200m price tag, and the organisation estimates that operators will need three such trainsets on each of the 16 slots, bringing projected investment costs to R600m per slot for third parties.

Moreover, it is widely understood that during the first phase of third-party access to TFR’s rail network, private sector operators will have ownership of the slots for only 24 months (from 2022 to 2024). ARIA says no private sector player has the risk appetite to invest large sums of money for equipment with a 30-year lifespan only to have access to the rail network for two years.

I think that if Transnet executives come to an information session, and they have not thought through the two years, and the costs of the locomotives and the rolling stock in general, there’s a problem.

Also according to the terms, Transnet will offer rail access on a voetstoots basis, meaning any infrastructure defects detected and uncovered on the slots will be for the third parties’ consideration. Transnet will neither provide nor guarantee security on the network, which has fallen victim to vandalism of rail track, and theft of overhead cables and signalling system equipment.

In 2021, TFR reported that there were more than 500 arrests made nationally in connection with the theft of rail equipment and pipeline products (mainly fuel).

On 8 April, TFR and Transnet group leadership held an information sharing session with an estimated 140 participants from the private sector, including ARIA members, Nhlapo, and banks’ representatives, about the terms and conditions of the slots sale.

“The slots sale information session held on 8 April was extremely well attended, with more than 70 participants attending in person and at least as many virtually. We have had interest, and indications that there are companies … [that] would like to progress discussions,” says Clement Maphaba, TFR’s manager for corporate affairs.

“It’s a long game. It’s not investment friendly. After the information sharing session, we saw that the terms are unreasonable,” Nhlapo says.

“I think that if Transnet executives come to an information session, and they have not thought through the two years, and the costs of the locomotives and the rolling stock in general, there’s a problem,” Nhlapo says.

Rail versus road

Since the mid-1990s, South Africa’s general freight – excluding coal and iron ore – has steadily moved from rail to road because of inefficiencies at Transnet, which has a monopoly on rail, and at the country’s ports and port terminals.

“I know there are trucks that go to the DRC [Democratic Republic of the Congo] from the North West carrying maize. That road transport is more efficient than rail,” Nhlapo says. “To get a service like that from a local operator, meaning Transnet, is a pain.

“It takes a long time to get results, whereas truck owners are more efficient and reliable.”
Despite the issues with the terms attached to the slots sale, Nhlapo says: “The opportunities are there. The infrastructure is underutilised. There is a … market for the private sector.”

“It is a good move. It’s long overdue,” says Jackie Walters, a transport economist at the University of Johannesburg.

“If you don’t have the capital costs, a two-year concession is going to work in the short term. It can work because your risks of entering will not be that high,” Walters says.

“But the big problem is security. Transnet can’t guarantee the coal line to Richard’s Bay, and it is looking at a force majeure on that. What will happen on the Durban line – and the other lines [being opened to third-party access]?” Walters says.

“Rail is depleted. Transnet can’t guarantee services. The only alternative cargo owners have is to use road transport,” Walters says.

“There [road], you have some guarantee of up-lifting. Although costly, you have time guarantees. You can operate factories on a just-in-time basis.

“But with rail you cannot do that. The service is so poor that most of the cargo has moved to road. We have to get the traffic back on to rail,” Walters says.

Understand Africa's tomorrow... today

We believe that Africa is poorly represented, and badly under-estimated. Beyond the vast opportunity manifest in African markets, we highlight people who make a difference; leaders turning the tide, youth driving change, and an indefatigable business community. That is what we believe will change the continent, and that is what we report on. With hard-hitting investigations, innovative analysis and deep dives into countries and sectors, The Africa Report delivers the insight you need.

View subscription options
Also in this in Depth:

Investors say South Africa’s ports need private investment to break inefficiency logjam

Improving South Africa’s ports, which rank among the most inefficient in the world, will need greater private-sector investment, executives and investors say.

Bolloré, MSC and the shake-up of maritime logistics in Africa

The negotiations for the purchase of Bolloré Africa Logistics comes at a time when the cards in logistics - from the seas to port infrastructures - have been shuffled by the Covid-19 crisis. The change has been accelerated by the significant capital gains made by the giants in the sector. It is up to Africa to take advantage of this.

Nigeria’s inadequate ports delay DHL’s plans to extend LCL container service

DHL wants to extend its less than container-load (LCL) service to Nigeria, but its plans are being delayed by lack of infrastructure at the country’s ports, Amadou Diallo, CEO of DHL Global Forwarding Middle East and Africa, tells The Africa Report.