The G20’s action on debt is an important first step; now for the hard part

In depth
This article is part of the dossier: Corona Chronicles: 20 April – 24 April
Brahima Sangafowa Coulibaly
By Brahima Sangafowa Coulibaly

Senior Fellow - Global Economy and DevelopmentDirector - Africa Growth Initiative

Donald Kaberuka
By Donald Kaberuka

Former President - African Development BankBoard Chair - The Global Fund

Louise Mushikiwabo
By Louise Mushikiwabo

Secretary General - Organisation Internationale de la Francophonie

Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala
By Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala

Nonresident Distinguished Fellow - Global Economy and Development, Africa Growth Initiative

Strive Masiyiwa
By Strive Masiyiwa

Founder and Executive Chairman - Econet Wireless International

Tidjane Thiam
By Tidjane Thiam

AU special envoy for COVID-19 response. Member of Global Board of Advisors - Council on Foreign Relations

Trevor Manuel
By Trevor Manuel

Former finance minister of South Africa. Appointed Special Envoy of the African Union to mobilise support in the fight against the Covid-19 pandemic.

Vera Songwe
By Vera Songwe

Executive Secretary of the United Nation's Economic Commission for Africa

Posted on Monday, 20 April 2020 16:02
Virus Outbreak Kenya
Brian Musasia Wanyande, a graffiti artist from the Mathare Roots youth group, works on an informational mural warning people about the risk of the new coronavirus, in the Mathare slum, or informal settlement, of Nairobi, Kenya Saturday, April 18, 2020. AP Photo/Brian Inganga

African countries, like others around the world, are contending with an unprecedented shock, which merits substantial and unconditional financial assistance in the spirit of Draghi’s “whatever it takes.”

The region is already facing an unprecedented synchronized and deep crisis.

At all levels—health, economic, social—institutions are already overstretched. Africa is almost at a sudden stop economically even before the full brunt of COVID-19 reaches its shores.

Economic performance for this year is projected to be worst in 30 years. The health crisis is morphing into full-blown economic, financial, and food crises.

LISTEN “This is a crisis where we need to act now” – IMF’s Abebe Selassie

These can be mitigated, but only if we act immediately and collectively, and with the full force of all resources that can be mobilized to get ahead of the pandemic.

Policymakers in advanced economies have, appropriately, thrown out policy orthodoxy and the same approach should be taken for the African countries.

The outcome of the G20’s Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors is an important first step that must be urgently complemented, scaled up, and broadened.

Following up on instructions of the G20 leaders, on April 15, the G20 Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors (G20 FMCBG) announced an action plan to bolster countries’ resources to respond appropriately to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Among the key recommendations, the communique calls for:

  • 1) swift implementation of the $200 billion emergency response packages adopted by the multilateral development banks,
  • 2) more contributions to replenish the Poverty Reduction and Growth Trust (PRGT) and the Catastrophe Containment Relief Trust (CCRT) and, very importantly,
  • 3) time-bound suspension of debt service payments for the poorest countries that request forbearance.

The announced action plan is broadly consistent with our previous call, but it does not go far enough.

The swift implementation of the support from the multilateral development banks and the replenishment of the Trust Funds at the International Monetary Fund will provide some much-need relief.

READ MORE G20 states postpone some of Africa’s debts but block cancellation

However, the share of these resources going to the African countries falls significantly short of the $200bn needed, as estimated by the African Union, and the debt standstill does not go far enough in its scope.

To truly empower African countries to effectively fight the virus and shore up the economies, we recommend the following next steps:

Expand the eligibility for the debt standstill

Countries classified as IBRD with a presumed ability to access market financing are excluded from the debt standstill. For Africa, this group of countries includes, Algeria, Angola, Egypt, Libya, Morocco, South Africa, and Tunisia.

Given the unique nature of the COVID-19 shock, the overriding criteria for eligibility for debt relief should be the need to effectively combat the pandemic and to prepare for durable economic fallout.

Under this provision, four of the top-five COVID affected countries—Algeria, Egypt, Morocco, and South Africa—are excluded from much-needed relief.

The fragile conditions in the civil-war ridden and oil-dependent Libya or the recent history of Tunisia as the epicentre of the Arab Spring upheaval point to further risks that merit consideration. If the pandemic is not eradicated in these countries, success in any of their neighbors will be short-lived given their interconnectedness.

READ MORE Coronavirus: Ethiopia’s opportunity to reboot its troubled transition

Similarly, the economic and financial spillover from distressed IBRD countries to the rest of Africa would be significant. These countries account for over 50 percent of Africa’s gross domestic product, and 46 percent and 55 percent of intra-regional exports and imports, respectively.

The consequences will also reverberate beyond Africa, given these countries account for a large share Africa’s imports from the rest of world, making up, for example, 72 percent of imports from the European Union, and are an important source of migration to Europe.

Indeed, migration challenges could rise multiple fold if the economies of the excluded countries collapse, further reducing job prospects for the burgeoning youth population.

Set up a process to ensure increased private creditors participation

The G20 FMCBG’s call for the private sector to join the debt relief, while welcome, must be bolstered by tasking the IMF to work with the Institute for International Finance (IIF) and the African Union to develop solutions guaranteeing debt sustainability and continued access to capital markets in the future.

Private sector debt is not only a higher share of African external debt, but it makes up a disproportionate share of the debt servicing cost. For several African countries, even where debt levels remain relatively low, the interest cost now accounts for 20 percent or more of government revenues.

Without significant private sector participation, the standstill will fall short of its objectives. Country participation in a standstill on the private debt should be voluntary. We believe it is in the long-term interest of countries classified as IBRD to participate, so there should be significant incentives in place to encourage their participation, using various levers described below.

Leveraging Special Drawing Rights

A viable and proven option for mobilizing additional resources includes Special Drawing Rights Allocations (SDRs). The endorsement of an initiative allocating more of the existing and unused SDRs to countries in need or even creating new ones—$500 billion, for example—would provide much-needed liquidity to central banks, the corporate sector, and SMEs.

Foreign exchange liquidity for the continent has dried up with capital flight and the collapse of commodity, notably oil, prices and trade, and tourism. Many countries are down to less than two weeks of reserves. The currencies of African countries have depreciated by 20-30 percent.

There is also an urgent need to shore up some central banks.

The African corporate sector does not have access to liquidity, as most funding sources have become unavailable or their requirements onerous. In addition, many companies—especially those in airlines, hotels, and tourism—have obligations to foreign commercial entities. Indeed, the regional African airline companies need about $1 billion to honor leasing obligations and other services alone. For businesses trying to avoid bankruptcy, there is need for working capital as well.

To adequately confront this funding crisis, we must be bold and innovative. We believe a special purpose vehicle could be created to serve as a bridge finance facility to be accessed on a voluntary basis. If adequately structured, participating countries would benefit from a lowering of their cost of debt whilst keeping their hardearned market access, and investors would hold paper that would be much more liquid and with enhanced credit. The multilateral institutions working with the IIF and Africa should be tasked to explore this option as they develop work outs for the bilateral debt.

Strengthen governance around the utilization of mobilized resources

With the benefit of immediate and substantial relief, African governments can now better focus on vulnerable populations and bolster safety nets and, like elsewhere in the world, support the private sector, especially SMEs, including paying arrears and ensuring minimal disruption to the flow of credit—thus avoiding deeper and more prolonged banking and economic crises.

In return, African countries must pledge to build and strengthen accountability and transparency, as well as enhance predictability.

READ MORE It’s not just about fresh capital for Africa: it is about deployment

Beyond enlisting the support of renown civil society organizations working in the field of transparency, African countries should also engage their technology hubs to help build an information database to track, monitor, and evaluate the use of these funds. Effective and balanced partnerships with these NGOs and tech platforms can ensure resources reach those most in need expeditiously.

This is not a moment for incrementalism or hesitation in policy response.

Strong and decisive action now will help avoid widespread sovereign defaults, contagion and chaos in the sovereign debt markets.

It will also help preserve millions of jobs on the continent, avoid widespread political and social unrest, and prevent insecurity and mass migration.

Understand Africa's tomorrow... today

We believe that Africa is poorly represented, and badly under-estimated. Beyond the vast opportunity manifest in African markets, we highlight people who make a difference; leaders turning the tide, youth driving change, and an indefatigable business community. That is what we believe will change the continent, and that is what we report on. With hard-hitting investigations, innovative analysis and deep dives into countries and sectors, The Africa Report delivers the insight you need.

View subscription options
Also in this in Depth:

Coronavirus: South Africa to ease lockdown to level 4 as of 1 May says Ramaphosa

South Africa will gradually reopen the economy on 1 May, when its lockdown will be eased to level 4, President Cyril Ramaphosa said in an address late Thursday.   

‘Coronavirus diplomacy’: China’s opportune time to aid Africa

China’s contribution to combatting COVID-19 around the globe has been striking. While Europe and the USA have become the epicentre of the pandemic in recent weeks, China is on the way to containing the new coronavirus (at least according to official statistics) at home. Its ability and willingness to offer humanitarian aid and lessons to other countries is generally welcomed. 

Nigeria’s health and economic crisis: Buhari left to face it without Abba Kyari

Even for a battle-hardened general, it has been a week out of hell for President Muhammadu Buhari; one of those weeks in which decades happen in a matter of days.  

Coronavirus: the miracle remedy touted by Madagascar’s Rajoelina

Madagascar’s president surprised many observers when he announced that certain traditional plants grown on the large island country have the potential to cure Covid-19. Was his mention of this African remedy based on the healing properties of traditional medicine premature given that it is still being studied?

Coronavirus: Nigeria’s travel industry shaky after N180 billion loss from pandemic

Nigeria's fledgling tourism industry is losing money and many jobs are being cut as employees are unable to pay wages, raising fears that the industry could collapse by the time the coronavirus pandemic ends.

A return to ‘business-as-usual’ will not benefit Africa in the long run

A few weeks ago, the mood was different. This was supposed to be Africa’s time yet again. Just like it was a decade ago when McKinsey declared Africa’s “Lions on the Move” - only for those hopes to disappear.

Coronavirus: private equity liquidity management is key to pandemic

Liquidity management will decide which private equity investors in Africa are able to take advantage of the new opportunities created by the coronavirus pandemic.

Interview: Bill Gates – ‘Coronavirus will cost far more than $3 trillion’

If anyone is allowed to say 'I told you so', it might be Bill Gates.

Art in the time of coronavirus

In the midst of this pandemic, holed up in our homes, many forget that the world of art hasn’t taken a back seat. It continues to inspire, to express ideas and to capture moments to comfort or entertain us and make us think.